I stumbled upon an article in the AARP magazine entitled, 5
happiest cities in America. There were
some surprises: Boulder, CO; San Jose, CA; Seattle, WA; Madison, WI: and
Honolulu, HI. The result was based on a Gallup Survey of the cities’ residents.
So, it reveals the perception of the residents that were surveyed. Certainly, if you perceive or believe that
you are happy, then you are. The article stated that the
Gallup survey suggests
that, with a few exceptions, the happiest residents dwell in midsize
cities — that is, big enough to avoid boredom, yet small enough to feel like a real community (and
actually find parking when you need it). Here's a sampling of the happiest
cities in America, where overall well-being is the overriding vibe.
In trying to understand the
results, I researched several characteristics of the cities – their geographic
location, weather patterns, and other physical characteristics – that may
contribute to the likability of a particular location. Madison
is a northern US city with very cold, and sometimes, long winters. The average monthly temperatures range from
10oF during the winter to a high of 83oF during the summer.
Honolulu
is on a tropical island paradise with average monthly temperatures ranging from
65oF to 88oF. Pleasant year-round temperatures, with tropical beaches, flora and
fauna provide a relaxing lifestyle for its residents, and one envied by many
mainlanders. Boulder,
Colorado is slightly cooler than Wisconsin in the summers as well as having slightly warmer winter temperatures. Interestingly,
Boulder is 5,344 feet above sea level which makes for thinner air, and
surrounding mountain ridges and canyons that facilitate lots of winter sports
as a result of its heavy snowfall. In
addition, residents of Boulder and the neighboring environs of Denver are
actively engaged in outdoor activities like road biking and jogging. Although Seattle
is located further north than Madison, it is generally warmer with far less
snow during the winters but experiences cooler summer temperatures. Seattle is known for its rainy climate,
between 3 and 6 inches during the winter months, but with temperatures warmer
than Wisconsin but chillier than Honolulu. Although the average temperatures between Seattle
and Boulder are not very different, the altitudes are remarkably dissimilar. The city of Seattle is primarily at low
altitude ranging from sea level to 520 feet.
So what about San
Jose? The average monthly temperatures
range from 42oF to 82oF and experiences rainfall measurements of 2 to 3 inches
during the Fall and Winter and less than 1 inch from May to October. These statistics seem to eliminate rainfall,
temperature, altitude, latitude, or longitude as contributing factors to
happiness. Weather appears not to be an overriding
factor that influences happiness.
So what are the factors that
contribute to happiness? Maybe a better
question would be, “What are the factors or experiences that do not appear to contribute to
happiness?” I was struck by the fact
that none of the top five were located in the South, usually characterized as the
Bible belt. These states are often characterized as conservative, and part of America’s
heartland; regions that pride themselves on their strong moral values, love of
country, independence, love of liberty, and so-called "second amendment rights."
A 2009 Gallup
tracking poll revealed that the ten states with the highest church
attendance in America are southern states, except Utah which was ranked at No.
5. Mississippi was No. 1. These southern
states also exhibit the lowest women’s
health outcomes. Lowest ranked were Mississippi, Arkansas, Idaho, Kentucky,
Louisiana, Kentucky, Tennessee, Oklahoma, and Texas. Other studies suggest that these states are
generally among the poorest, the fattest and politically conservative. Residents of the happiest cities are often
regarded as liberal, educated, amoral and atheistic. But is it surprising that the unhappiest
people live in regions of America where there appears to be in a perpetual fight against
the President, the government, immigration, taxes, their congress, and virtually
everything about modern day American society and perpetually engaged in what they call a culture war?
I consider myself fairly conservative in my lifestyle
choices. My religious beliefs have been
a major factor in my outlook on life and I consider myself to be very happy and
content with life – all as a result of my religious outlook. (I am reminded of a song I learnt as a child:
“I have a joy in my heart to stay.”) I believe in a Christianity that expresses
thankfulness, generosity, and peace of mind; a Christianity that seeks for the
happiness of all. True religion should
embody a love of the citizen and the alien, the weak and strong. Christianity or religion that is meaningful
should seek to protect the vulnerable among us; seek to serve the poor and dispossessed
and actively demonstrate external serenity.
A religion that simply seeks self-preservation and hoarding of resources is a sad religion and
makes for an unhappy people. So, I end
his blog with a question to ponder. Does it mean that religion, or at least the
claims of religion, does not play a significant role in happiness among Americans? Maybe, just maybe, it is the way religion is practiced
that generates those unhappy people in those unhappy states and cities.
2 comments:
Hi Len,
I think that you are right that Faith is still fundamentally linked to happiness. The problem with the southern states might not be their faith but the fact that most of those states are part of the economic class that has suffered the most over the last twenty to thirty years.
The one common characteristic for the five cities that are named is that these are homes to the "Bobos in Paradise" class, the new creative elites who are inversely reaping the disproportionate rewards of our Ayn Rand infused economy.
Bab Al-Mandeb: Thanks for your comments. We tout Christianity (and most religions for that matter) as the source of inner peace, joy and happiness, not only in this life but in the hereafter. My broader question was why that seems not to be the case among the mostly religious South but presumably evident in the less religious enclaves of America. That, at least seems to be the perception.
Post a Comment